| Saturday, November 6th, 1909 |
| New York Yankees: CF Bob Ganley received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Yankees: 3B Hans Lobert received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Yankees: SP Elmer Stricklett received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Yankees: CF Dode Paskert received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Yankees: LF Bill Hinchman received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,308. |
| New York Yankees: SP Dan McClellan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| Boston Red Sox: RF Walt McCredie received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Boston Red Sox: RF Red Murray received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,345. |
| Boston Red Sox: CF Rube Oldring received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Boston Red Sox: C Tommy Raub was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Boston Red Sox: 3B Rabbit Robinson was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Boston Red Sox: SP Jimmy Dygert received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Boston Red Sox: SP Doc Scanlan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago White Sox: 1B Hal Chase received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,632. |
| Chicago White Sox: MR George Disch received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago White Sox: 1B Claude Rossman received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,680. |
| Chicago White Sox: CF Tris Speaker received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,993. |
| Chicago White Sox: C Peaches Graham received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,365. |
| Chicago White Sox: RF Otis Clymer received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago White Sox: SP Jack Coombs received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,130. |
| Chicago White Sox: 2B Charlie Malay received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago White Sox: SP Orval Overall received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,616. |
| Chicago White Sox: LF Tom O'Hara received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago White Sox: SP Eddie Cicotte received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: 2B Amby McConnell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: LF Harry Niles received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: 1B Dode Criss received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: 2B Whitey Alperman received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: SP Heinie Berger received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,687. |
| Cleveland Naps: MR Elijah Jones received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: 1B Del Howard received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,660. |
| Cleveland Naps: SP Frank Smith received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,561. |
| Cleveland Naps: SP Ed Killian received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: CL Cy Vorhees received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cleveland Naps: SS Alan Storke received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Detroit Tigers: C Oscar Stanage received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,597. |
| Detroit Tigers: SS Charley O'Leary received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: RF Jack Dunleavy received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: CL Joe Harris received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,794. |
| St. Louis Browns: SP Elmer Steele received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: C Nig Clarke received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,118. |
| St. Louis Browns: CF Johnny Bates received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,252. |
| St. Louis Browns: 2B Dave Shean received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: 1B Tom Jones received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: RF Art Williams received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Browns: SP Mike Lynch received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Philadelphia Athletics: CF Solly Hofman received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,224. |
| Philadelphia Athletics: 2B Otto Knabe received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Washington Senators: C Art Hoelskoetter was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Washington Senators: SP George Bell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Washington Senators: SS Ed Holly was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Washington Senators: SP Rube Kroh received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Washington Senators: MR John Halla was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: RF Pinky Swander received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $2,100. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: RF Denny Sullivan was not offered arbitration, becomes a free agent. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: MR Bill McGill received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: SP Nap Rucker received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,445. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: CF Joe Birmingham received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,340. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: SS Pop Lloyd received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $2,010. |
| Brooklyn Superbas: SS Andy Sullivan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Atlanta Braves: CL Bob Dresser received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Atlanta Braves: 2B Larry Doyle received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| Atlanta Braves: SS Al Bridwell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Atlanta Braves: SP Frank Corridon received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Atlanta Braves: 1B Ed Konetchy received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago Cubs: LF Moose McCormick received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,980. |
| Chicago Cubs: SP Walter Johnson received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $2,000. |
| Chicago Cubs: CL Irv Young received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Chicago Cubs: SP Jack Rowan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: SP Ed Karger received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: RF Harry Lumley received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $3,059. |
| Cincinnati Reds: MR Fred Burchell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: LF Spike Shannon received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| Cincinnati Reds: SP Jim Buchanan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,703. |
| Cincinnati Reds: 2B Pug Bennett received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: RF Mike Mitchell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: RF Goat Anderson received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: CF Harry Armbruster received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,350. |
| Cincinnati Reds: 3B Mike McCormick received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Cincinnati Reds: 3B Mike Mowrey received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,680. |
| New York Giants: 3B Roy Hartzell received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Giants: 2B Heinie Zimmerman received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| New York Giants: SP Lefty Leifield received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| New York Giants: SP Harry Coveleski received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: CF Chet Chadbourne received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,840. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: C George Gibson received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: 1B Dave Altizer received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,500. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: SS Mickey Doolan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: 2B Joe Delahanty received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: CF Clyde Milan received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,144. |
| Philadelphia Phillies: C Gabby Street received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Pittsburgh Pirates: MR Ray Tift received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Pittsburgh Pirates: CF Jack Barnett received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| Pittsburgh Pirates: 3B George Moriarty received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,290. |
| Pittsburgh Pirates: RF Fred Snodgrass received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| Pittsburgh Pirates: MR Biff Schlitzer received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Cardinals: SP Doc Reisling received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Cardinals: SP Joe Wood received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,858. |
| St. Louis Cardinals: 2B Larry Gardner received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,553. |
| St. Louis Cardinals: 3B Eddie Grant received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |
| St. Louis Cardinals: MR Hi West received a 1-year contract through arbitration worth a total of $1,115. |